How to Give Feedback to Someone More Senior Than You
- What upward feedback actually is
- Why most upward feedback fails
- The four moves that work
- Make it a daily practice
Giving feedback to someone in a more senior position may feel daunting, yet it is an essential skill for fostering a healthy workplace culture. Many professionals instinctively shy away from these conversations, fearing repercussions or misinterpretation of their intentions. However, when executed correctly, upward feedback can significantly enhance your professional relationships and even bolster your career trajectory. It communicates confidence, builds trust, and positions you as a valuable contributor in the eyes of senior leaders.
What Upward Feedback Actually Is
Understanding the essence of upward feedback is crucial. It is not about grumbling or sharing unfounded critiques; rather, it is a means of providing specific, observable insights about behaviors that impact team dynamics or organizational outcomes. The goal is to present your observations in a constructive manner that enables the recipient to improve.
Many senior leaders yearn for honest feedback but rarely receive it, leaving them unaware of how their actions affect their teams. Research from the Center for Creative Leadership indicates that 360-degree feedback for senior leaders leads to the most significant behavioral changes, provided that the feedback is specific and behavior-focused. In contrast, vague feedback often results in vague responses or no response at all, perpetuating a cycle of misunderstandings and missed opportunities.
Why Most Upward Feedback Fails
Several pitfalls can sabotage upward feedback attempts. The first is poor framing. When individuals deliver feedback with hesitant language, it signals uncertainty. Phrases like "I might be wrong, but..." can undermine the message, causing the senior leader to disengage.
Another common issue is bad timing. Waiting too long to address an issue can lead to frustration, while addressing it too soon may result in emotional outbursts. The ideal window for providing feedback is typically 24-72 hours after the situation, allowing for a level-headed conversation in a private setting.
The third failure mode is targeting the wrong audience. It is crucial to ensure that you direct your feedback to the appropriate person. Miscommunication can arise when feedback intended for a direct report is given to their superior, leading to misunderstandings and a sense of being ambushed.
The Four Moves That Work
To effectively deliver upward feedback, consider these four key moves:
1. Wait for the Right Moment, but Not Too Long.
Find a balance between emotional distance and timely communication. Aim to deliver feedback within a couple of days of the observed behavior to maintain relevance.
2. Open with a Clear Ask for Permission.
Start the conversation with a statement like, "Can I share an observation from yesterday's meeting?" This approach not only indicates that you have something specific to discuss but also engages the senior leader in the feedback process, making them an active participant.
3. Use the SBI Framework — Situation, Behavior, Impact.
This structured approach allows you to present your feedback clearly. For example, you might say, "In yesterday's planning meeting, when you interrupted Sarah, it caused a noticeable drop in engagement from the team." This method eliminates ambiguity and focuses on concrete actions.
4. Offer One Concrete Suggestion.
Conclude with a specific recommendation for improvement, such as, "I believe pausing before responding when someone is speaking could enhance the discussion." Providing a solution empowers the senior leader and gives them a tangible action to consider.
Make It a Daily Practice
Many professionals give upward feedback only a couple of times a year, resulting in a lack of fluency in this important skill. To build confidence, aim for smaller feedback moments more frequently. Even dedicating five minutes each day to reflect on minor observations can reinforce the habit of giving upward feedback.
Micro-learning can be particularly effective here. Instead of enrolling in a lengthy course, focus on quick lessons that address specific challenges you might face when giving feedback. For instance, you might learn how to address a process that isn’t working or how to push back on a decision in a one-on-one meeting.
The best upward feedback givers are not necessarily fearless; they have practiced their skills enough that the structure of their feedback becomes second nature. The more you engage in these conversations, the more routine they will feel.
Practical Example
Consider the case of Eli, a senior engineer at a SaaS company. During team meetings, his VP often interrupted team members, stifling discussion and engagement. Instead of complaining about it behind closed doors, Eli approached his VP after a meeting and said, "When you cut Sarah off today, I noticed the room fell silent. This has happened in larger meetings, and I thought you’d want to know."
The VP was initially taken aback but appreciated Eli’s honesty and subsequently changed his behavior. As a result, Eli positioned himself as a trusted advisor. While he faced some competition for promotions, his ability to provide candid feedback led to him being entrusted with significant projects.
Conclusion
As you begin to practice upward feedback more frequently, you will likely observe positive changes in your professional relationships. Senior leaders will start to appreciate your insights, and you’ll find that your own grievances decrease as you address issues in real-time. Ultimately, the leaders who receive honest feedback become better at their jobs and, in turn, create a more open and productive work environment.
The key takeaway is that delivering upward feedback effectively—being specific, timely, and constructive—will make you an invaluable asset in your organization.
Ready to enhance your feedback skills? Take the Omie Skill Assessment and discover personalized lessons that can help you become a more effective communicator in your workplace.